Welcome to More Than Pizza Ithaca, a trusted Pizza Restaurant in Ithaca, NY, where great food and friendly service come together. With a 4.50-star rating from 104 reviews, we’re proud to serve guests looking for fresh pizza and memorable meals.
At More Than Pizza Ithaca, our Pizza Restaurant in Ithaca, NY is known for quality ingredients, warm hospitality, and a relaxed dining experience. Rated 4.50 by 104 reviews, we also offer great service and quality and accessible facilities to make every visit easy and enjoyable.
If you’re searching for a standout Pizza Restaurant in Ithaca, NY, More Than Pizza Ithaca is a great place to satisfy your pizza cravings. Backed by a 4.50-star rating and 104 reviews, we combine delicious flavors, convenient service, and a welcoming atmosphere.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at More Than Pizza Ithaca
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
Halal falafel over rice with options for red sauce, white sauce, or no sauce.
Halal beef gyro over rice with options for red sauce, white sauce, or no sauce.
Grilled chicken marinated in mediterranean spices topped with lettuce, tomato , tzatziki sauce and feta cheese served on pita bread.
Halal chicken shawarma over rice. Options for red sauce, white sauce, or sauce-free.
Halal chicken and gyro over rice, options include red sauce, white sauce, or sauce-free.
Halal falafel pita with sauce options: red, white, or none.
Halal chicken wrapped in pita with options for red or white sauce, or served without sauce.
Halal chicken shawarma in pita bread. Options for sauce: red, white, or none.
Halal beef gyro wrapped in pita bread with options of red sauce, white sauce, or sauce-free.
Straight cut fries seasoned with garlic and salt, topped with parmesan cheese.
5 Mozz Sticks
Garlic-infused knots of warm, freshly baked bread with a flavorful twist.
Deep-fried balls of ground chickpeas and herbs, typically includes tahini sauce.
Ground chickpeas and herbs form the base of our falafel hummus, complemented by tahini and olive oil, typically served with a side of warm pita bread.
Pureed chickpeas blended with tahini, lemon juice, and garlic, served with pita bread.
A Jamaican patty filled with curried beef, encased in a flaky, buttery crust, typically seasoned with a blend of spices.
Buffalo chicken served on a sub roll, typically includes hot sauce, bleu cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes.
BBQ chicken, garnished with lettuce and tomato, typically includes melted cheese, all enveloped in a toasted sub roll with barbecue sauce.
Breaded chicken cutlet, marinara sauce, and provolone cheese on a toasted sub roll, typically includes a topping of parmesan cheese.
Layered eggplant in marinara, topped with melted Parmesan cheese
Italian meatballs in marinara sauce, topped with parmesan cheese on a toasted sub roll.
Thinly sliced steak, sautéed onions, and green peppers, typically includes American cheese, served on a sub roll.
Mix of Chicken & Philly Steak all in one!
Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese, typically served over pasta.
Layered eggplant in marinara, topped with melted Parmesan cheese
Pasta with marinara sauce, typically includes meatballs topped with melted parmesan cheese.
Italian sausage, typically simmered in a homemade marinara sauce, topped with melted provolone and a sprinkle of grated Romano cheese, served over pasta.
Tender Ziti Pasta in a Rich Tomato Sauce, Baked with Mozzarella Cheese
Classic spaghetti and meatballs in our homemade marinara sauce.
10 PC
Chicken tenders available in 5 or 10 piece options. Choice of chicken sauce: no sauce, hot, buffalo, mild, bbq, honey BBQ, garlic parm. Side sauce options ranging from ranch to mustard.
Chicken wings, options for sauce include hot, buffalo, BBQ, or garlic parm. Choose from 5 or 10 pieces. Side sauces range from ranch to mustard.
Ground beef patty served on a bun, typically includes lettuce, tomato, and onions, with a blend of ketchup and mayonnaise.
Quarter pound of angus beef served with mayo, ketchup, lettuce, tomato and cheese.
Juicy beef patty, crispy bacon, melted cheese, in a toasted bun.
Half pound of angus beef served with mayo, ketchup, lettuce, tomato and cheese.
Grilled chicken breast served with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and mayo on a toasted bun.
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, banana peppers, green olives, black olives and shredded mozzarella. served with dressing on the side and garlic knots.
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, banana peppers, black olives and feta cheese. served with dressing on the side and garlic knots.
Mixed greens, crispy falafel, available in small or large sizes.
Romaine lettuce, tomato, croutons and parmesan cheese. served with garlic knots.
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, tomato, croutons and parmesan cheese. served with garlic knots.
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, banana peppers, green olives, black olives, shredded mozzarella, spicy chicken. served with dressing on the side and garlic knots.
Crispy fries, available in small or large sizes.
Cheese fries, available in small or large, topped with melted cheese.
Curly fries, available in small or large sizes.
Curly fries topped with melted cheese. Available in small or large sizes.
Crispy onion rings, available in small or large sizes.
Variety of calzones: Greek, Veggie, Hawaiian, and 9 more, including meat options. Choose from 11 side sauces like Ranch, Blue Cheese, and Garlic Butter.
Medium Gluten Free Pie
Medium-sized pizza topped with mozzarella. Choice of side sauces: ranch, blue cheese, garlic butter, hot to mild flavors, BBQ, honey BBQ, ketchup, mustard.
Large Cheese Pizza: Mozzarella atop a golden crust. Choice of side sauce: from ranch to buffalo, including sweet options like honey BBQ.
Extra-large pizza with choice of side sauce ranging from ranch to mustard.
Half sheet Sicilian pizza, optional side sauces include ranch, blue cheese, garlic butter, hot sauces, and more.
Thick, square pizza with your choice of sauce on the side: ranch, blue cheese, garlic butter, various spicy and BBQ options, ketchup, or mustard.
Medium specialty pizza options include Greek, Veggie, Margarita, White Garlic, Eggplant, various chicken combinations, Pepperoni, Sausage Pepperoni, Meatlovers, Philly, Hawaiian. Side sauce choices from ranch to mustard.
Large pizza with choice of Greek, veggie, margarita, or various chicken and meat options. Optional side sauce: ranch to mustard, including BBQ and buffalo variants.
Extra-large pizza options including Greek, Veggie, Margarita, White Garlic, Eggplant, BBQ Chicken, and more. Choose from 11 side sauces like Ranch or Blue Cheese.
Sicilian 1/2 sheet pizza. Choice of side sauces from ranch to mustard. Greek, veggie, margarita, and more specialty pie options available.
Sicilian sheet pizza, choose from sauces like ranch or garlic butter, specialties including veggie, BBQ chicken, or Hawaiian.
Classic New York Cheesecake: Rich, Creamy, with a Silky Smooth Texture.
Classic Italian dessert made with ladyfingers soaked in coffee, layered with mascarpone cheese and dusted with cocoa.
Sweet and flaky pastry filled with nuts, honey, and aromatic spices
Decadent Chocolate Brownie, Perfectly Moist and Rich in Flavor
Crispy, Soft-centered Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie
Pure, crisp hydration, essential for any moment.
Selection of teas: Pure Leaf Unsweetened, Gold Peak Sweet Tea, and Arizona Green Leaf Tea.
Sports drinks available in red, orange, yellow, or white.
Snapple tea in various flavors: kiwi, mango, apple, peach, plus lemon lime and strawberry tea with zero sugar options.
Energizing Red Bull Beverage for an Instant Energy Boost
A power-packed energy drink to keep you energized and focused.
20oz bottled soda. Choose from Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mnt Dew, Ginger Ale, Starry Lemon Lime, or Orange Crush.
Assorted soda cans: Pepsi varieties, Mountain Dew selections, Ginger Ale, Mug Rootbeer, Starry Lemon Lime, Orange Crush, and Dr. Pepper options, including strawberries & cream flavors.
2l soda options include Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mnt Dew, Starry Lemon Lime, and Ginger Ale.
Hear from our valued guests
My daughter and I dined here Friday night. I wanted something fast and easy because it was past her bedtime and I picked the perfect spot. It wasn’t crowded the restaurant was cozy and warm and everyone was welcoming and friendly. The food was great thank you !
One of the top places to eat good food in Ithaca. Love their platers options. Also, they provide a wonderful catering service
INCREDIBLE! the owner was incredibly nice ! Mediterranean pizza was outstanding! And to top it off we got the falafel! Fresh, crisp, delicious. I am so happy we stopped in. He is the real deal! So good!
They have everything here you would want for lunch or an easy dinner. A variety of pizza options sandwiches, and quick service. Try the chicken parm slice!
Amazing pizza and relatively fast service, good place to go if you just want to stop in for some pizza
Great food Price meets tge value for sure Great service and nice environment And love how much options there are for everything food and drinks.
I was visiting Ithaca from out of town and stopped by More Than Pizza – and I’m so glad I did! The staff was incredibly welcoming and made me feel right at home. Their kindness and hospitality truly stood out. On top of that, the food was amazing – fresh, delicious, and made with care. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this place is a must-visit. Highly recommend!
We really wanted some halal food on the trip to Ithaca from NYC. After looking at some halal spots we decided for More Than Pizza, and it didn't disappoint. We got a bacon cheeseburger and Chicken over rice, both were fantastic!
There is definitely more than pizza. They have halal meat over rice. I had the chicken & gyro mix over rice in Large. It was great. Reminded me of the food trucks in NYC and Philly. Hard to say which I prefer. Maybe the mix is the way to go! The portion is decent. Enough left for me to have lunch the next day. High value for the price. The owner is welcoming and friendly. Will definitely come again.
Context: My partner and I came in on a Friday at midnight. There were only college students as customers who were coming in. They were still putting out fresh pizza at this time. Food: I ordered a mixed chicken and gyro dish over rice ($14). It came with a basic salad. The chicken was tender and moist, the gyro was flavorful, and the rice had the perfect texture. All were seasoned well and the sauces on top were a good balance of creamy and spicy. The salad was also crispy and cold (though pretty basic and not a lot of it). The portions were generous overall for the price, making this a good value. Atmosphere: The store was brightly lit and had both booths and tables for eating at, though the store is small overall. They also have outdoor seating. They had salt, black pepper, red pepper, and Parmesan as condiments on the tables, as expected for a (more than) pizza place, but no halal food sauces readily available. The only thing I could complain about was the flyer they had out that informed customers that they give a 4% discount for paying with cash instead of card (which we comfirmed with the cashier). We paid in cash and they just removed a few cents off our bill to give a round number, much less than 4%. 4% ends up being a small discount, but why even advertise this if you're not going to abide by it? Conclusion: If their pizza is as good as their halal dish was, then I would probably come again just to try the pizza (they sell whole pies, but also sell $3-4 per large slice). I highly recommend their halal food!
Common questions about More Than Pizza Ithaca
More Than Pizza Ithaca is located at 215 E State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States, Ithaca, NY, United States.
You can reach More Than Pizza Ithaca by calling +1 607-319-0791.
More Than Pizza Ithaca has a rating of 4.5 out of 5 based on 104 customer reviews.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair-accessible seating, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following service options: Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, On-site services, Takeaway, Dine-in.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following offerings: Comfort food, Late-night food, Quick bite.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following dining options: Lunch, Dinner, Catering, Counter service, Dessert, Seating.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following amenities: Gender-neutral toilets, Restroom.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following atmosphere: Casual.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following crowd: Family friendly, Tourists, University students.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following planning: Accepts reservations.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following children: Good for kids, High chairs.
More Than Pizza Ithaca features the following pets: Dogs allowed outside.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
